Your earnout becomes debt the day it is earned
Posting this because it comes up constantly in searcher deals and almost never gets modeled. The structure most of us use: bridge a valuation gap with an earnout, partly because the seller wants a number you can’t underwrite, partly because contingent consideration stays out of the opening leverage calculation. That second part is true. It is also temporary. Rough numbers from a deal shape you’ll recognize. $16.0M purchase, 5.0x on $3.2M EBITDA. $9.6M senior, $3.4M equity, $3.0M earnout over two years. Opening leverage 3.00x against a 3.50x covenant, FCCR covenant at 1.20x. Year two, the business performs. EBITDA $3.8M. Earnout targets hit. $3.0M becomes due and payable. Leverage test: $10.6M total debt over $3.8M EBITDA is 2.79x against a 3.25x step-down. Passes. Coverage test: EBITDA $3.8M less $350K maintenance capex less $550K cash taxes gives $2.90M available. Fixed charges were $720K interest plus $1.0M amortization, so 1.69x. Add the earnout and fixed charges are $4.72M. Coverage is 0.61x. Default, because you hit your numbers. Two mechanics drive this. First, contingent earnouts carried at fair value are generally excluded from leverage, but earnouts that are due and payable often are not. The exclusion was always time-limited. Second, where Fixed Charges is defined to capture scheduled payments of Indebtedness, the earnout walks into that definition the moment it becomes Indebtedness. Nobody makes a decision; the definitions just connect. The installment instinct does not save you. $1.0M a year gives 1.07x, still a breach. Solve for the ceiling: at $2.90M available and 1.20x required, fixed charges max out at $2.42M, leaving about $700K a year for the earnout. A $3.0M earnout needs more than four years to fit, which is longer than most sellers will carry and longer than most earnout periods run. What to ask for at signing, when it’s free: 1. Exclude contingent consideration from Indebtedness until paid, not until payable. A few words. 2. Carve the earnout payment out of Fixed Charges, or make it a permitted restricted payment conditioned on pro forma compliance. The lender keeps its protection and you lose the automatic breach. 3. If you’d fund a successful earnout with new equity anyway, write that in and make the payment conditional on the contribution. 4. Set the covenant test date after the payment on a pro forma basis, so the ratio measures the business rather than a one-time outflow. None of this is the lender behaving badly. A $3.0M cash call is a real claim and a facility that ignores it is mispriced. But the treatment of earnouts, guarantees and other hybrids is negotiated rather than standard, so lenders differ on it far more than they differ on price. If you only compare term sheets on rate and leverage, you are comparing the two things that vary least. Worth adding: entry multiples right now are unremarkable. The Fed’s Financial Stability Report from last week puts newly issued loans with debt multiples of 4x or more around the historical median, while the median interest coverage ratio for private leveraged borrowers sits near its historical low. The binding constraint has moved from leverage to coverage. Most of the negotiating energy has not moved with it. Happy to talk through specific structures if it’s useful.