Why the Broker’s E-commerce P&L Rarely Matches the company’s financials: Cash-to-Accrual Conversions That Only Go Halfway
We do Quality of Earnings work, a good part of it on SBA-financed deals. In e-commerce, one problem comes up again and again: the P&L in the CIM doesn’t match the seller’s books, and when we rebuild it the earnings come out lower. Usually nobody is trying to mislead anyone. Most small e-commerce businesses keep cash-basis books, and brokers try to “fix” that by converting to accrual. The trouble is that they often convert only the revenue side. Here are the issues we see most often. If you’re looking at an e-commerce deal right now, they’re worth checking: 1. Revenue goes to accrual, costs stay on cash The broker pulls gross sales from the Shopify or Amazon report for the period, which is effectively accrual-basis revenue. That’s a reasonable step. The costs, though, stay exactly as they were in the cash-basis books. Inventory purchases are expensed when paid, not when the goods are sold. If the seller stocked up before, or held back on purchases in the last few months before going to market, COGS for the period can be badly off in either direction. The result is accrual revenue next to cash costs. Gross margin and EBITDA can look much better than they really are, and the gap tends to be widest around seasonal peaks and right before a sale. Those are exactly the periods buyers should focus on. 2. Platform and payment processing fees disappear in the conversion This one is subtle, and it’s the one we find most often. On cash basis, many sellers book revenue as the bank deposit. Shopify Payments, Stripe, PayPal, Amazon and Shop Pay all pay out net of their fees. The fees are never recorded as an expense, but that’s fine on cash basis because revenue is already understated by the same amount. It nets out. When the broker replaces the revenue line with gross sales from the Shopify report, for example, that offset is gone. Revenue goes up by the full gross amount, but nobody adds back the expense that used to be buried in the net deposit. The fees simply vanish from the P&L: • Payment processing fees (typically ~2.5–3.5% of GMV, depending on the processor and the mix) • Amazon referral and FBA fees, which on Amazon-heavy businesses can be the single largest cost after COGS • Shopify subscription, apps, and transaction fees for merchants using third-party gateways • Marketplace fees from Etsy, Walmart, TikTok Shop, etc. A simple example: a store does $3M in gross sales and the processor charges 3%. The books show about $2.91M in deposits as revenue, with no fee expense. The broker restates revenue to $3M gross and leaves expenses untouched. That’s $90K of EBITDA that doesn’t exist. At a 3–4x multiple, that’s $270K–$360K of purchase price. What we’d suggest as a buyer 1. Ask the broker exactly how they did the conversion. If revenue was adjusted, ask what they did to COGS, ad spend, and fees. 2. Reconcile Shopify/Amazon/processor payout reports to bank deposits. The difference between gross sales and deposits should be explainable line by line: fees, refunds, chargebacks, reserves, taxes. 3. Recalculate fees as a percentage of GMV and compare against the P&L. If you can’t find them, they’re probably missing. 4. Get monthly data, not just annual totals. Timing distortions only show up month by month. 5. Look hard at the last 3–6 months before the listing. That’s where purchases get deferred and spend gets cut. None of this means the business is bad. It means the number you’re paying a multiple on should be built consistently, with revenue and costs on the same basis. Happy to compare notes with anyone working on e-commerce deals.