Insurance Brokerage Roll-Up Strategy

searcher profile

October 18, 2025

by a searcher from University of Toronto in Toronto, ON, Canada

I’m partnering with an existing insurance brokerage owner who’s looking to grow through acquisition as part of a broader U.S. roll-up strategy. We’re less concerned about licensing logistics and more focused on the intangibles that make a brokerage valuable beyond the book. Things like the brand’s local reputation, client trust, producer relationships, and what gets lost (or needs to be preserved) during integration. Would love to hear from anyone who’s navigated this before, how did you balance maintaining legacy goodwill and culture while still achieving operational and brand alignment across acquired agencies?
1
2
103
Replies
2
commentor profile
Reply by a searcher
from Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University in Philadelphia, PA, USA
I currently source "off-market" insurance agencies for a client on the East Coast, doing something similar and has acquired 30+ so far. Because they are targeting a specific geography, they may not be in direct competition with you, and may be open to sharing info around this. Feel free to DM me to connect and discuss.
commentor profile
Reply by a searcher
from Boston College in Atlanta, GA, USA
Geoff, are your clients active in the south east?
Join the discussion