How to handle oversubscription on equity?

January 23, 2026

by a searcher from Columbia University in New York, NY, USA

I have a deal that I'm looking to close that is oversubscribed on the equity. While this is a good problem, I'm interested in any thoughts on the right method and timing with which to let some of my interested backers off the hook without injuring a relationship, and without leaving myself open to a flake at the closing table.

1 Like

8 Replies

183 Views

Replies

Reply by an investor
from Université Catholique de Louvain in United Kingdom

It’s a great position to be in. I’d advise locking in your core, reliable and strategic backers first, especially investors you genuinely feel you can work well with, and building in a modest margin of safety to protect against last-minute issues. If you expect to raise follow-on capital post-close (e.g. buy-and-build, capex, or expansion), you may also want to prioritise a broader cap table than if you don’t. Then scale remaining investors back pro-rata if needed, with some discretion for strategic or cornerstone investors. Once docs and debt are largely locked and closing risk is low, release excess demand early enough for them to redeploy capital, framing it as respect for their time and capital rather than a rejection.

Reply by an investor
from University of Virginia in Charleston, SC, USA

I agree with the comments above. Also look at your leverage level. All searchers and investors for that matter underestimate the investment needs so if you are pushing at 3x this may be an opportunity to bring that leverage down and give you more ability to reinvest back in the business. This is a good problem for you and will give you a clearer head in really evaluating the amount of cash on the balance sheet and the right level of investment you may need in the business in the first 18 months.

+6 more replies.

Join the discussion