How Do You Choose a Quality of Earnings Provider?
How to compare QoE firms on scope, independence, experience and the report itself, with the questions to settle before anyone signs an engagement letter.
redactedKey Insight
Choose a quality of earnings provider on four things: the scope it will deliver, who it works for, whether its experience fits the deal and the lender, and whether its report ties each adjustment to evidence. QoE findings are behind a growing share of broken deals, at least on one platform. In Axial's Dead Deal Reports, QoE EBITDA discrepancies were the reason in 16 of 75 broken LOIs inredacted%), up from 10 of 65 inredacted%) and 5 of 47 inredacted%). Other diligence findings were the single most common reason in 2025, at 19 ofredacted%). These are shares of lower middle market deals that broke, from small samples on one platform. They are not a failure rate.
The short answer:
settle who is commissioning the report first, because on a financed deal the lender may want to. Then put the scope in writing, confirm the provider has no stake in the deal closing, match its experience to the industry and the deal size, and read a redacted sample report. Compare quotes only against the same scope, and pick the firm whose report a skeptical reader could trace, adjustment by adjustment, to documents.
Continue reading ...